Casey shared a moment with Tanya instead of either of his love interests (Picture: ITV)

Love Island fans weren’t impressed with Casey O’Gorman in this evening’s challenge when he failed to kiss either of his love interests.

Claudia Fogarty, 28, was left in tears after Casey, 26, was picked by brunette bombshell Rosie Seabrook, 24, in the latest recoupling.

Since, Casey has talked of not wanting to hurt Claudia’s feelings, while also admitting to being interested in getting to know newbie Rosie.

But in tonight’s devils and angels challenge, Mr Nice Guy Casey didn’t go in for the kiss with either beauty – and Love Island viewers weren’t impressed.

Instead, he kissed his friend Tanya Manhenga, explaining that doing so was an ‘easy option’.

Some fans commented on how this was a ‘boring’ choice, and hinted that the Islander should have played his cards more boldly.

Claudia was pretty upset when Casey was picked by newbie Rosie as her new partner (Picture: ITV)

Casey and Claudia shared a kiss when it was her go in the challenge (Picture: ITV)

Rosie didn’t hold back while talking about Casey and Claudia’s relationship (Picture: ITV)

‘Casey picking Tanya was so boring’, wrote one fan, while another worried that Tanya being Casey’s ‘easy’ option ‘just feels weird’.

‘Oh c’mon it’s obvious from the Saturday unseen bits that Tanya is the easy option for Casey because they are like brother and sister in there,’ another wrote.

Claudia and Casey were coupled up for a few days before the dreaded (and much anticipated) Casa Amour villa split, after which they decided to stay together.

That’s until a Rosie-shaped spanner came along after it was revealed Casey shared a few steamy moments in the Casa Amor villa, and the pair’s romance seemed a little less promising.

The latest challenge came after Rosie expressed her concerns at the potential for Casey and Claudia’s blossoming relationship.

‘I feel like the only couple that I think weren’t compatible were Casey and Claudia,’ she told Samie Elishi and Sanam Harrinanan.

Casey is torn between two women at the moment (Picture: ITV/Shutterstock)

But that is yet to be seen, as the episode finished with Casey and Claudia catching up over a classic Love Island ‘where’s your head at’ chat.

‘I do really like Rosie. The more I’m speaking to her the more I’m starting to like her,’ said Casey, before admitting that he didn’t ‘feel ready to make that decision’ when Claudia asked who he wants to pursue a relationship with.

‘You’ve got to do what you’ve got to do,’ Claudia said, having walked out of the bedroom last night after hearing some cosy pillow talk between the new couple.

More: Trending

‘I’m worth more,’ Claudia told Casey as she warned she won’t stick around forever, before he concluded: ‘I don’t know where I’m at’.

Tomorrow’s excitement is the classic snog, marry pie challenge, so hopefully Love Island viewers will be entertained by that one, as it usually sends the villa into chaos.

Love Island returns tomorrow at 9pm on ITV2 and ITVX.

Got a story?

If you’ve got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us [email protected], calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we’d love to hear from you.

MORE : Love Island’s Claudia Fogarty storms out of bedroom as Casey O’Gorman enjoys pillow talk with Rosie Seabrook

MORE : Love Island’s Zara Lackenby-Brown slams show for not setting her up with Jordan Odofin: ‘I deserved to find love’

Eek.