Close Menu
WTX News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Who will win the 2025 F1 world title? Our writers have their say
    • Regretting You director: ‘I wanted Colleen Hoover to have a good experience on this one’
    • North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul
    • Archer to miss ODI as England step up Ashes prep
    • Burj Al Khazzan reimagined for a sustainable Riyadh
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    WTX News
    • Live News
      • US News
      • EU News
      • UK News
      • Politics
      • COVID-19
      • Business
      • Tech zone
    • World news
      • Middle East News
        • UAE News
        • Palestine News
      • Europe
        • Italian News
        • Spanish News
      • Africa news
      • South America
      • North America
      • Asia
    • News Briefings
      • UK News Briefing
      • World News Briefing
      • Live Business News
    • Sports
      • Football News
      • Tennis
      • Women’s Football
    • MY World
      • Climate Change
      • In Review
      • Expose
      • Special Reports
        • Conscience Convoy
        • Rohingya Report
    • Entertainment
      • Insta Talk
      • Royal Family
      • Gaming News
      • TV Shows
      • Streaming
    • Lifestyle
      • Fitness
      • Fashion
      • Cooking recipes
      • Luxury
      • Money Saving Expert
    • Travel
      • Culture
      • Holidays
    • Sign Up
      • Log In
    WTX News
    • Live News
    • World news
    • News Briefings
    • Sports
    • MY World
    • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Sign Up
    Home - World News - Ukraine pushes for NATO membership, but it’s complicated
    World News Updated:December 4, 2024

    Ukraine pushes for NATO membership, but it’s complicated

    By Olga Winter - EU Newsdesk4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Ukraine pushes for NATO membership, but it’s complicated

     

    Article 5 is the cornerstone of the NATO military alliance. It calls on all members to assist any other NATO countries under attack. Exactly how a member decides to aid allies, however, is up to them.

    Since Russia’s February 2022 invasion outgoing US President Joe Biden has repeatedly vowed, “We will defend every inch of Ukraine.” Now Kyiv would like to slip under that umbrella of protection permanently. NATO has repeatedly said that this will be the case, without, however, setting a date. At some point, some observers think, Ukraine should be rewarded with NATO membership for its years-long defensive battle against Russia.   

    NATO protection for part of Ukraine?

    Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has now proposed allowing those parts of Ukraine that are free to join the alliance. Russian occupied areas in Eastern Ukraine as well as the illegally annexed Crimean peninsula (comprising some 27% of Ukraine), he said, would be excluded from joining for now. Zelenskyy hopes the move will thwart any further Russian advances, making negotiations for a ceasefire with Russian President Vladimir Putin possible.  

    Technically, it would be possible to give Ukraine partial protection under the NATO Treaty. That is something that could be articulated in Ukraine’s accession document, which must be ratified by all 32 NATO member states. Article 14 of the NATO Treaty’s Supplemental Protocol already makes provisions for similar questions. Article 6 of the treaty outlines what regions are defined as NATO territories. Numerous French and UK islands in the Caribbean or South Pacific, for example, are not defined as NATO territories. During the post-WWII partitioning of Germany into the FRG (West Germany) and the GDR (East Germany), only the West was covered by the treaty. East Germany was a member of the Soviet Union’s military alliance, the Warsaw Pact.

    Many NATO members not backing the idea

    The question is whether Western partners — above all the most important of these, the US — have the political will to grant membership to those parts of Ukraine that remain free. German security experts, for instance, warn that such a move would greatly increase the risk of dragging NATO partners into the conflict between Russia and Ukraine. When German Chancellor Olaf Scholz visited Ukraine on Monday, he voiced clear opposition to the plan proposed by Zelenskyy. Former NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg sees things differently. Shortly after stepping down as head of the alliance in October, Stoltenberg said fast-tracking NATO membership for Kyiv could end the war.

    “Where there is a will, there is a way to find a solution. But you need a line which defines where Article 5 is invoked, and Ukraine has to control all the territory until that border,” Stoltenberg told the Financial Times newspaper. France, Poland and the Baltic states have all signaled that they could envision partial membership for Ukraine.

    Hard to predict the ‘Trump factor’

    When outlining his “victory plan,” Ukrainian President Zelenskyy has repeatedly called for NATO security guarantees for his country. Germany’s Major General Christian Freuding, who leads the Bundeswehr’s Planning and Command Staff, says Ukraine’s “back is against the wall.” That is why Zelenskyy has said he could imagine dropping plans to win back territory occupied by Russia. Russian President Vladimir Putin has, among other things, demanded NATO reject Ukraine’s bid to join the alliance, even partially.

    It is unknown how incoming US President-elect Donald Trump will see things. The Wall Street Journal recently cited sources in Trump‘s inner circle as saying the new president may be looking to delay Ukraine’s NATO membership “by 20 years.” It is also unclear what Trump has in mind when he claims that he will end the war.

    NATO boss Mark Rutte: more weapons, less talk

    Speaking at the current meeting of NATO foreign ministers in Brussels, NATO’s new Secretary General Mark Rutte said Ukraine doesn’t need any new discussions about how to attain a ceasefire, it needs more arms and more missile defense capabilities.

    “I would argue, let’s not have all these discussions step-by-step on what a peace process might look like” said Rutte, emphasizing that the alliance must “make sure that Ukraine has what it needs to get to a position of strength when those peace talks start.” It is from this position of strength that Ukraine should negotiate with the Russian aggressor.

    This article was translated from German by Jon Shelton

    Ukraine pushes for NATO membership, but it’s complicated – DW – 12/03/2024

    News Just in

    North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul

    Olga Winter - EU Newsdesk

    North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul, they were not aimed at South Korea, but could be construed as a warning to the US fleet.

    Read More »

    DW News featured
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Previous ArticleThe repentant Di Matteo: “The mafia killers on free leave and I, on the other hand, no longer protected”
    Next Article Trump leans on Hunter Biden pardon to push hush money conviction reversal
    Olga Winter - EU Newsdesk
    • Facebook
    • X (Twitter)

    Olga Winter is a specialist editor writing about current affairs on the EU news desk for WTX News. Based in Brussels she ideally suited to the address the domestic and global affairs of the European continent, with assignments that include expose and In Review features for specialist reports..

    Related Posts

    North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul
    World News

    North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul

    Why Southeast Asia’s fight against smoking isn’t over
    World News

    Why Southeast Asia’s fight against smoking isn’t over

    Two die as cargo plane skids off Hong Kong runway into sea
    World News

    Two die as cargo plane skids off Hong Kong runway into sea

    Japan coalition to back Takaichi as first woman PM
    World News

    Japan coalition to back Takaichi as first woman PM

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Advertisment
    News Headlines
    North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul

    North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul

    Burj Al Khazzan reimagined for a sustainable Riyadh

    Burj Al Khazzan reimagined for a sustainable Riyadh

    Save 70% on VIP subscription
    News Briefings - the way to a better life
    News Briefings - the way to a better life
    Advert by Sponsors
    More from WTX News
    The latest gaming news - with game reviews and tips and tricks. updated 24 hours a day.
    The latest gaming news
    Hot off the press!
    • Who will win the 2025 F1 world title? Our writers have their say October 22, 2025
    • Regretting You director: ‘I wanted Colleen Hoover to have a good experience on this one’ October 22, 2025
    • North Korea fires ballistic missiles, says Seoul October 22, 2025
    • Archer to miss ODI as England step up Ashes prep October 22, 2025
    • Burj Al Khazzan reimagined for a sustainable Riyadh October 22, 2025
    WTX News latest breaking news sports and travel
    Latest News and analysis - Deciphering through the BS with exclusive News Briefings
    Facebook X (Twitter) TikTok Instagram

    News

    • World News
    • UK News
    • US News
    • EU News
    • Business
    • Opinions
    • News Briefing
    • Live News

    Company

    • About WTX News
    • Register
    • Advertising
    • Work with us
    • Contact
    • Community
    • GDPR Policy
    • Privacy

    Services

    • Fitness for free
    • Insta Talk
    • How to guides
    • Climate Change
    • In Review
    • Expose
    • NEWS SUMMARY
    • Money Saving Expert

    News delivered to your inbox

    Copyright WTX News 2025

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.