Close Menu
WTX News
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Trending
    • Sikh woman raped in ‘racially aggravated attack’ speaks out
    • Why Alexander Isak is ready for the spotlight at Liverpool
    • “I was hooked straight away”: TV fans reveal Netflix’s best crime dramas
    • China warns UK and US after USS Higgins and HMS Richmond sail through Taiwan Strait
    • India vs Pakistan minus the fervour
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    WTX News
    • Live News
      • US News
      • EU News
      • UK News
      • Politics
      • COVID-19
      • Business
      • Tech zone
    • World news
      • Middle East News
        • UAE News
        • Palestine News
      • Europe
        • Italian News
        • Spanish News
      • Africa news
      • South America
      • North America
      • Asia
    • News Briefings
      • UK News Briefing
      • World News Briefing
      • Live Business News
    • Sports
      • Football News
      • Tennis
      • Women’s Football
    • MY World
      • Climate Change
      • In Review
      • Expose
      • Special Reports
        • Conscience Convoy
        • Rohingya Report
    • Entertainment
      • Insta Talk
      • Royal Family
      • Gaming News
      • TV Shows
      • Streaming
    • Lifestyle
      • Fitness
      • Fashion
      • Cooking recipes
      • Luxury
      • Money Saving Expert
    • Travel
      • Culture
      • Holidays
    • Sign Up
      • Log In
    WTX News
    • Live News
    • World news
    • News Briefings
    • Sports
    • MY World
    • Entertainment
    • Lifestyle
    • Travel
    • Sign Up
    Home - News Briefing - Jeremy Hunt’s Treasury may have broken the law by hiding Budget black hole, says OBR
    News Briefing Updated:November 6, 2024

    Jeremy Hunt’s Treasury may have broken the law by hiding Budget black hole, says OBR

    By David Pike3 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Jeremy Hunt’s Treasury may have broken the law by hiding Budget black hole, says OBR

    Jeremy Hunt’s Treasury may have broken the law by hiding Budget black hole, says OBR

    Treasury officials under Jeremy Hunt “broke the law” by failing to report a black hole in the public finances to the Office of Budget Responsibility (OBR), MPs have been told.

    Richard Hughes, chair of the watchdog, made the accusation to the Commons Treasury select committee during a hearing on the Budget.

    It comes amid a row over claims made by Rachel Reeves that Mr Hunt failed to disclose a £22bn spending gap ahead of the election. The OBR has since suggested that the real figure was £9.5bn – but that it nevertheless made a difference to its own calculations.

    Mr Hunt has denied the existence of a black hole in the public finances, but the OBR’s position raises questions about his actions, and those of permanent secretary to the Treasury James Bowler.

    Mr Hughes suggested to MPs on the Treasury Committee on Tuesday that there may have been a “misunderstanding” about the law that governs disclosures.

    Last week, the OBR confirmed that the previous government “did not provide” all available information at Mr Hunt’s last Budget in March.

    It said it had uncovered £9.5bn in spending pressures that it was not made aware of ahead of that fiscal statement, and that its judgement on spending would have been “materially different” had it had access to that information.

    Mr Hughes told the committee that he had asked the Treasury what spending pressures it was aware of at the time of the March Budget.

    Chancellor Rachel Reeves announced £40 billion of additional taxes in her Budget (PA Wire)

    “The short answer was there was about £9.5bn worth of net pressure on departments’ budgets, which they did not disclose to us … which under the law, and under the act, they should have done,” he said.

    Asked later in the session if he thought the Treasury had broken the law, Mr Hughes said: “They didn’t provide all of the information that we required to do our forecast.

    “Now, there is always information that is relevant to the work that we do, which we would like to have. In this case, this was a material amount of information, which would have led to a materially different forecast had we had it.”

    He said that there had been a “systemic failure” in the last forecast, and that there may “have been a misunderstanding” of how the law ought to be interpreted.

    “There is no doubt in our minds that, had that information been provided, we would have had a materially different judgement,” he added.

    Asked if Downing Street thought Tory ministers had withheld information, Sir Keir Starmer’s spokesperson said: “At the Budget last week, the OBR published a review of the issues surrounding the £22bn black hole and how it came about, and the government has accepted all the recommendations made by the OBR, including recommendations around the previous processes being too informal.

    “Now, obviously I can’t speak to previous administrations. But the general principle is that officials’ engagement with institutions like the OBR is obviously on the basis of ministerial policy positions. And you’ve got the chancellor’s previous words that, in the end, civil servants advise, and ministers decide.”

    https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/jeremy-hunt-treasury-black-hole-budget-b2641914.html

    Keir Starmer The Independent UK featured UK politics
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email Telegram WhatsApp
    Previous ArticleDonald Trump projected to win the US election 
    Next Article Robert Fisk: University to set up public archive on work of renowned The Independent journalist
    David Pike

    David Pike is an experienced news journalist with over 20 years experience as a UK News editor for WTX News and other news publications.

    Related Posts

    Sikh woman raped in ‘racially aggravated attack’ speaks out
    UK News

    Sikh woman raped in ‘racially aggravated attack’ speaks out

    China warns UK and US after USS Higgins and HMS Richmond sail through Taiwan Strait
    China

    China warns UK and US after USS Higgins and HMS Richmond sail through Taiwan Strait

    Sainsbury’s recalls own-brand hummus over potentially deadly E.coli warning
    UK News

    Sainsbury’s recalls own-brand hummus over potentially deadly E.coli warning

    BlackRock to invest £500m in UK data centres during Trump visit
    Politics

    BlackRock to invest £500m in UK data centres during Trump visit

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Advertisment
    News Headlines
    Sikh woman raped in ‘racially aggravated attack’ speaks out

    Sikh woman raped in ‘racially aggravated attack’ speaks out

    China warns UK and US after USS Higgins and HMS Richmond sail through Taiwan Strait

    China warns UK and US after USS Higgins and HMS Richmond sail through Taiwan Strait

    Save 70% on VIP subscription
    News Briefings - the way to a better life
    News Briefings - the way to a better life
    Advert by Sponsors
    More from WTX News
    The latest gaming news - with game reviews and tips and tricks. updated 24 hours a day.
    The latest gaming news
    Hot off the press!
    • Sikh woman raped in ‘racially aggravated attack’ speaks out September 13, 2025
    • Why Alexander Isak is ready for the spotlight at Liverpool September 13, 2025
    • “I was hooked straight away”: TV fans reveal Netflix’s best crime dramas September 13, 2025
    • China warns UK and US after USS Higgins and HMS Richmond sail through Taiwan Strait September 13, 2025
    • India vs Pakistan minus the fervour September 13, 2025
    WTX News latest breaking news sports and travel
    Latest News and analysis - Deciphering through the BS with exclusive News Briefings
    Facebook X (Twitter) TikTok Instagram

    News

    • World News
    • UK News
    • US News
    • EU News
    • Business
    • Opinions
    • News Briefing
    • Live News

    Company

    • About WTX News
    • Register
    • Advertising
    • Work with us
    • Contact
    • Community
    • GDPR Policy
    • Privacy

    Services

    • Fitness for free
    • Insta Talk
    • How to guides
    • Climate Change
    • In Review
    • Expose
    • NEWS SUMMARY
    • Money Saving Expert

    News delivered to your inbox

    Copyright WTX News 2025

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.