Redfall – loveably imperfect? (pic: Microsoft)

A reader explains why he’s still intrigued by Redfall, despite all the bad press, and lists other less than perfect games he’s enjoyed.

The recent release of Redfall has been a sour affair, at a time Xbox really needed a hit they released what both critics and gamers have perceived as a misfire. I have not played the game yet (though thanks to Game Pass, I will), but it got me thinking of the games I’ve played over the years and what I’ve realised is that sometimes I prefer games that are imperfect or mediocre.

Though I don’t believe the perfect games exists, there are games that come strikingly close to that. Anything by Naughty Dog (The Last Of Us Part 1 PC port being an outlier) has been perfectly paced, brilliantly written, and polished within an inch of its life. The Forza Horizon series is always stellar, most Mario games absolutely nail everything. And don’t get me wrong, I love these games, but there’s something about them that can leave me feeling cold. They feel clinical, riskless, dare I say… boring.

But I have a great fondness for games that maybe score 6s and 7s, not the disasters like Life Of Black Tiger but games that took a few swings and had a few misses, but for the most part created an endearing experience in its own right.

ReCore

ReCore is a semi-open world platformer/shooter. It’s really difficult for me to put this game in a category or even compare it to another game, as I can’t think of a game that’s anything like it. It toes the line between realism and cartoon, making it a strange hybrid with weirdly satisfying colour co-ordinated combat and challenging but fair platforming. Plus, the robots are dead cute and fun to use.

I really liked this game, the lead character was really endearing, the story was decent and kept me engaged to the end. Its drawbacks were middling graphics, samey open world areas, and technical issues that plagued the initial release – insanely long loading times being the biggest bug bear.

But the Definitive Edition of the game addressed the majority of these problems and expanded the game’s story and altered the exploration in an interesting way. This game is worth your time and was totally slept on due to middling reviews.

The Order: 1886

The Order: 1886 had a lot going for it pre-release, it had that sexy PlayStation AAA sheen and the graphics were fantastic and still look top notch eight years later. What many put this game down for, I think makes it so good. It was short, but sweet.

The one issue I have with a lot of games these days, is they are arbitrarily padded with fluff to increase the playtime [cough] God Of War Ragnarök. But I actually appreciated the length and linearity of The Order: 1886, I didn’t need this world to be open and I didn’t need filler levels. It was concise and I appreciated it.

My biggest gripe was the game not using the werewolves to their fullest potential. But I liked this game and absolutely adored the steampunk style, shame we never got a sequel.

Croc: Legend Of The Gobbos

Often maligned for being a lesser game than Crash Bandicoot, Croc was a fun little adventure that had way more in common with Spyro The Dragon than Crash. But herein lies the game’s issue, Spyro was much more refined and was the better game.

This was detrimental to Croc, as it was massively overshadowed by other family friendly platformers that dominated the space at the time. Croc did have some issues with controls, with the character feeling a little bit weighty and unwieldly when performing an attack.

Croc did get a sequel, so it wasn’t all doom and gloom, but this sort of dark but cute platformer had a lot to like and yet little Croc may never be seen again!

Atomic Heart

I have two big issues with this game. For starters, the protagonist is so dull and dreary. I have to wonder what on earth they were thinking, especially when Granny Zina is right there and would have made for a far more compelling character (as well as more interesting, having an elderly woman as the main protagonist). My second issue is the controls, to me, don’t always flow the way I want them to and can make some of the combat encounters a bit of chore.

But by god this game’s atmosphere and world design are fabulous and despite the story sometimes chugging from time to time, it’s still pretty fun to play, warts and all.

High On Life

High On Life truly divided critics, but audiences seemed to be far more receptive to the game and it looks like it did very well on Game Pass. What I liked about High On Life was that though the combat and parkour weren’t the most engaging things in the world, it was all uplifted by a crazy and unique world.

Comedy games are few and far between, so it was refreshing to me to play something that really didn’t take itself seriously. A lot of your enjoyment in High On Life would depend on whether the humour landed or not; luckily for me, it landed more often than it didn’t.

I had an absolute blast playing High On Life and, dare I say, despite some short comings it might have been the most fun I had with a game last year. Sorry Elden Ring.

Conclusion

These games have been maligned and are often touted online as being trash or mediocre, but do you know what? Sometimes I like it when a game doesn’t get it all right, sometimes I like the annoying quirks, you can feel a certain passion seeping through when a game isn’t as polished.

I will play Redfall at some point and I will make my own choices about what I like and don’t like about the game, but if it’s anything like the above maybe it’ll be more special to me than the game of the year… maybe. Either way I refuse to get sucked into the hyperbolic mudslinging gamers do when a game doesn’t get 10/10.

By reader Jay

The reader’s feature does not necessary represent the views of GameCentral or Metro.

You can submit your own 500 to 600-word reader feature at any time, which if used will be published in the next appropriate weekend slot. Just contact us at [email protected] or use our Submit Stuff page and you won’t need to send an email.

MORE : Twitch streamer xQc roasts Zelda: Tears Of The Kingdom graphics: ‘Telephones are better’

MORE : New Game Pass trial for PC is the cheapest way to play Redfall says Xbox

MORE : Xbox deflects Redfall controversy by announcing Starfield showcase date

Follow Metro Gaming on Twitter and email us at [email protected]

To submit Inbox letters and Reader’s Features more easily, without the need to send an email, just use our Submit Stuff page here.

For more stories like this, check our Gaming page.

A reader explains why he’s still intrigued by Redfall, despite all the bad press, and lists other less than perfect games he’s enjoyed.